New show you might want to try

As you miss SPN, you might wanna try Wynonna Earp (some spoilers for the pilot)
It's got the SPN things going -
Rural USA, creatures that can blend in, a little cowboy, a little western, messed up family+secrets, curse, normal+safe, sisters, magical gun, research clipping wall, 'babygirl'....

just with Jessica Jones starring as Dean

and done not so well